Faculty of Management/Faculty of Science Joint Ethics 
Committee: Reviewer Assessment Form

[Email this review to saul@cpsc.ucalgary.ca]

Reviewer:


Date:


Project Title:




Principal Investigator:



1. RISK. 
   a) Has the applicant identified all relevant risks 
      (question 2 on the application)? 

    ___YES
    ___NO:add comment below



   b) Is the risk rating appropriate to an expedited review 
   
   ___None or Minimal Risk
   ___More Than Minimal Risk:add comment below 


   c) Has the application dealt appropriately with the risks, if any? 

    ___YES
    ___NO: add comment below


   d) Do you have any further comments/concerns about the risk 
   component of this study?




2. Please comment on whether the following aspects of the proposal are reasonable  as well as consistent with the guidelines for ethics in human research:
    a) Participant recruitment, withdrawal, and debriefing (question 5):

    ___OK
    ___Some concerns: add comment below



    b) Benefits (question 6):

    ___OK
    ___Some concerns: add comment below



    c) Confidentiality, anonymity, and data storage (question 7):

    ___OK
    ___Some concerns: add comment below



    d) Informed consent (question 8 and attached form, if applicable):

    ___OK
    ___Some concerns: add comment below




    e) Other aspects of the study and application:

    ___OK
    ___Some concerns: add comment below




3. Your recommendation for this proposal (please check one):
   ____ Approved (with or without minor changes)
   ____ Needs revision and further review

4. Other comments you might have: