Contrasting Stack-Based and Recency-Based Back Buttons on Web Browsers

Greenberg, S., Ho, G. and Kaasten, S. (2000)
Contrasting Stack-Based and Recency-Based Back Buttons on Web Browsers. Research report 2000-666-18, Department of Computer Science, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada, August. This version was updated in January 2002, original report is also available.

View Publication and Related Materials

PDF PaperPDF Paper (2000-StackRecency.Report2000-666-18.pdf)

Abstract

People frequently use the ubiquitous Back button found in most Web browsers to return to recently visited pages. Because all commercial browsers implement Back as a stack, previously visited branches of the tree are pruned; this means that people can quickly navigate back up the tree. The problem is that previously seen pages on alternate child branches are no longer reachable through Back. An alternate method is to implement Back on a recency model, where all visited pages are placed on a recency-ordered list with duplicated removed. This means that all previously seen pages are now available via Back. Because advantages and trade-offs exist in both methods, we performed a study that contrasted how people used stack vs recency-based Back. We found that people have a naïve mental model of how the conventional stack-based Back works, typically perceiving it as a recency list. People are also poor predictors of what pages will be displayed with both types of Back buttons. Finally, people seem evenly split over their preference of a stack vs. recency-based Back button.

Bibtex entry

@TECHREPORT { 2000-StackRecency.Report2000-666-18,
CLASS = { REPORT },
AUTHOR = { Greenberg, S. and Ho, G. and Kaasten, S. },
TITLE = { Contrasting Stack-Based and Recency-Based Back Buttons on Web Browsers },
INSTITUTION = { Department of Computer Science, University of Calgary },
ADDRESS = { Calgary, Alberta, Canada },
YEAR = { 2000 },
MONTH = { August },
NUMBER = { 2000-666-18 },
NOTE = { This version was updated in January 2002, original report is also available },
}